Skip to content
Brian TrumanThe Truman Experience

← All articles

Should You Price High and Leave Room to Negotiate?

By Brian Truman · John L. Scott – West Seattle · About 2 minutes

Published October 19, 2026

Price high only when the evidence and your strategy support it, not simply because negotiation is expected. An asking price influences who sees the home, how buyers compare it, and what they expect when they arrive.

The useful question is whether your price attracts the buyers most likely to appreciate the property and complete a purchase.

Start with the alternatives buyers see

Compare recent relevant sales and the homes currently competing with yours. Consider condition, layout, parking, views, and location rather than choosing the highest nearby sale as the target.

Ask what a buyer would think after touring your home and its competition. If another property offers more at a similar price, your strategy needs an explanation grounded in real differences.

Review factors such as:

  • The condition and presentation of your home.
  • The available comparable properties.
  • Your preparation budget and timetable.
  • How much uncertainty you can tolerate.

These are better starting points than adding an arbitrary cushion to the desired proceeds.

Understand the cost of testing a price

A higher asking price may reduce interest from buyers whose searches stop below it. It may also set expectations that the home does not meet during a showing.

Time on the market is not automatically a problem, but it should produce information. If buyers repeatedly choose competing homes, waiting without reviewing the evidence is not a complete strategy.

Decide how you will evaluate the response

Before listing, agree on what you will monitor. Showings, inquiries, feedback, competing listings, and offers each provide a different piece of the picture.

Low activity may suggest one issue; strong showing activity without offers may suggest another. Avoid treating every comment as a command, but look for patterns worth investigating.

Separate your goal from market value

The amount you need for your next purchase matters to your moving plan. It does not independently establish what a buyer will pay for the current home.

If the likely range does not support your goals, discuss preparation, timing, or other options before committing to a listing strategy.

A realistic plan can still be ambitious. It should connect the asking price, the property's position, and the way you will respond to evidence.

Let's compare your home with the choices buyers have and choose a price strategy that fits your goals and the market.

Let's make your next move clear.

Tell Brian your area, goals, and timeline. Start with a practical conversation.

Talk with Brian

Browse the FAQs · Explore Brian's experience

General educational information. Confirm legal, tax, lending, insurance, and property-condition questions with the appropriate qualified professionals.